Comments on Indian GST Reform 2016

By: Ravi Singhania
Date: 13-Oct-2016

Undoubtedly the passing of the GST Constitutional Amendment Bill by Rajya Sabha is a landmark in the annals of India’s fiscal reform after independence. It is bigger than the tax reform by Raja Chelliah and Manmohan Singh, and the introduction of VAT in 2004. The Goods and Services tax unifies the Indian market for goods and services into a single market with a common tax code and hopefully a single rate (18 % RNR) on a pan India basis. It removes the barriers to the movement of goods and services within India.
The tax system and administration will also be based on a superior tax design and uniform threshold limits for covering the maximum units of tax payers in the system to expand the tax base to support lower and moderate tax than an extortionate tax system. Hopefully India will hold fast to a moderate tax regime to curb the inflationary impact of a higher GST rate. To make the Indian export in the global market competitive this is a must. This has been a selling point for the GST reform which can be a game changer only if it makes our export internationally competitive.
Services which constitute over 50 % of the GDP are bound to become more expensive with a higher rate of GST and this is a forbidding thought for consumers of services both at an industry and individual level. The actual impact is difficult to express at this stage.
On the contra side, a poorly administered GST with the state-machinery working at cross- purposes would defeat the purpose of a single code and single rate and uniform interpretation. The dual system of GST which means a two tier Central and State assessments and collection and initiation of audits and refund processes, is fraught with the risk of local distortion in individual States and the tax payer may yet suffer from an inefficient, untrained and corrupt tax administrators. The pain of transition to a new system has been felt in Malaysia which also adopted GST recently, and the Indian experience may be hit by our own unique set of problems.
The GST operates through an IT Infrastructure which is likely to be implemented and go through trial runs only after the legislations have been finally passed by the States. This is a critical component and how quickly the tax paying companies and other entities doing business can mesh their own systems into GSTN is a question of adopting new systems all across the country. One can only be optimistic and hope for the best at least in the short to medium term.
Finally, the entire ecosystem in the manufacturing and service supply chain has also to fit into the requirements of GST and how quickly this is done by all the stakeholders will be a challenge that should not be underestimated for the smooth transition and implementation of the GST.
It is best to avoid euphoria and to prepare for a checklist of what can go wrong so that all the players, and above all the Central and State governments, are willing and ready to intervene when bottlenecks and hurdles are encountered. This is a huge experiment on a huge scale and tax administration must be prepared to assist tax payers without the old suspicions of the past and in a genuine spirit of understanding. Remember, implementation is the key as industry and business would need a period of trial and error to adapt their systems and unless approached in the right sprit, businesses may suffer.

Comments (13)

A.K.Pandey says on 21 Jun 2018

Hi Admin,Thanks for sharing this blog with us, I read your article, your blog contains very important information to us, I appreciate your effort. its look like you have GST Expert level of knowledge.

Reply
AKGVG Associates says on 26 Oct 2021

Thank you for sharing this blog with us, I read your article, and this article contains very important information for us, which shows that you have knowledge of GST expert level.

Reply
lalegitimate says on 14 Jul 2022

Good day. I am a private loan lender that gives out both business and personal loans to individual at a low interest rate of 2% no matter your location. If you are interested Contact me (Whats App) number: 917310847059 sumitihomelend@gmail.com Mr. Sumiti

Reply
Finleg says on 12 Aug 2022

Finleg is one stop that provides GST Registation services , tax and compliances filing, business registrations and documentation services to businesses

Reply
CA Divya jain says on 12 Sep 2022

Get GST Registration online. We help you with the GST Registration process and provide the Best GST Registration Services in India.

Reply
Gst refund says on 24 Sep 2022

Thanks for such amazing content in your blog. The blog was very informative. To know more about GST refunds you can visit My GST Refund

Reply
Nikita Rai says on 11 Oct 2022

Thanks for sharing this amazing article with us. This post is really very informative.Thanks!It’s great to come across a blog like this, fantastic read! And best topics in your blog.

Reply
Varun Kumar says on 03 Nov 2022

Hello Admin, I read your article, It contains very important information. Even this article also useful GST Billing Software.

Reply
taxpartner says on 28 Feb 2023

Very helpful article, thank you for providing the information...The process of GST registration and GST return filing is necessary for any business that intends to comply with the GST laws in India. This process is relatively simple and can be done online. Learn more about GST registration at - https://www.ourtaxpartner.com/registration-service/gst-registration/

Reply
taxpartner says on 28 Feb 2023

Very helpful article, thank you for proviLearn more about GST registration at GST Registration Consultantsding the information...

Reply
alok consultancy says on 07 Apr 2023

Top Digital Signature Consultant in India | Alok Consultancy Digital signatures have become an essential tool for businesses in India. They help in streamlining business processes, reducing paperwork, and ensuring the security of electronic transactions. With the increasing demand for digital signatures, many consultancy firms in India have started offering digital signature services. Here we discuss the top digital signature consultant in India – Alok Consultancy. Top Digital Signature Consultant Top Digital Signature Consultant in India Alok Consultancyhttps://alokconsultancy.com/top-digital-signature-consultant-in-india-alok-consultancy.html 011-4309 5656 91 85878 62586 info@alokconsultancy.com

Reply
finbook says on 04 May 2023

very well explained the topic, I am wondering if you had explored more on point no 5, it wud be more helpful ... Anyways I am loving your blog and blogs from finbookbusiness.com

Reply
finbook says on 04 May 2023

very well explained the topic, I am wondering if you had explored more on point no 5, it wud be more helpful ... Anyways I am loving your blog and blogs from finbookbusiness.com

Reply

Comments on Indian GST Reform 2016

Comments on Indian GST Reform 2016

Comments (13)

A.K.Pandey says on 21 Jun 2018

AKGVG Associates says on 26 Oct 2021

lalegitimate says on 14 Jul 2022

Finleg says on 12 Aug 2022

CA Divya jain says on 12 Sep 2022

Gst refund says on 24 Sep 2022

Nikita Rai says on 11 Oct 2022

Varun Kumar says on 03 Nov 2022

taxpartner says on 28 Feb 2023

taxpartner says on 28 Feb 2023

alok consultancy says on 07 Apr 2023

finbook says on 04 May 2023

finbook says on 04 May 2023

Post Comments

Search

Other Articles / Blogs by the Author

Practice Areas

Archives

Authors