Validity of Invocation of Bank Guarantee to be Judged on Facts Of Each Case: Supreme Court

Validity of Invocation of Bank Guarantee to be Judged on Facts Of Each Case: Supreme Court

Legitimacy of invocation of bank guarantees has always been a bone of contention between the parties who have entered into commercial arrangements. While the general view of the courts in India has been that invocation of bank guarantee should generally be not interfered by the courts when challenged, as it will defeat the purpose of such guarantees in commercial contracts. However, there is no dearth of judicial pronouncements against invocation of bank guarantees albeit in exceptional circumstances.

A bank guarantee is a written contract given by a bank on behalf of its customer. By issuing this guarantee, a bank takes responsibility for payment of a sum of money in case, if it is not paid by the customer in performance of its contractual obligations.

There are two types of bank guarantees:

  • Unconditional bank guarantee- In anunconditional bank guarantee, the bank/guarantor has to pay the guarantee amount to the beneficiary in whose favour the bank guarantee has been issued on demand, irrespective of any pending disputes;
  • Conditional bank guarantee- In a conditional bank guarantee, the bank/guarantor has to pay the guarantee amount to the beneficiary in whose favour bank guarantee has been issued on demand, only after the specific conditions for invocation in the contract are fulfilled.

The law with respect to the grant of injunction against invocation of bank guarantee has been settled by catena of judicial pronouncements. Courts have consistently held that an unconditional bank guarantee, which is an independent agreement between beneficiary and the Bank, can be invoked by the beneficiary, regardless of the disputes between the beneficiary and principal obligation (i.e. the party on whose behalf the bank guarantee has been given).

It is a settled position that invocation of unconditional bank guarantee cannot be stayed by the courts except

  • In case of fraud which would destroy the very purpose for which such bank guarantee was issued
  • In a case where encashment of the bank guarantee would result in irreparable harm or injustice to one of the parties concerned. In view of the aforesaid settled position, a party seeking stay against invocation of the bank guarantee used to find it very difficult, nay impossible, to obtain favourable order.

However, in its recent pronouncement, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India seems to have made a paradigm shift by holding that each case of injunction against invocation of the bank guarantee has to be decided with reference to the facts involved therein. The Apex Court in Gangotri Enterprises v. Union of India held that while there can be no quarrel to the proposition laid down in the cases pertaining to encashment of bank guarantees, the same would not be applied in every case. Holding that the in the case in hand, law laid down in the case of Union of India Vs. Raman Iron Foundry was applicable, the apex court reversed the judgment of Allahabad High Court which declined to grant injunction against invocation of bank guarantee by beneficiary party.

The present ruling of the Supreme Court has widened the so far restrictive parameters with which a case of grant of injunction against bank guarantees were being consider by the courts. The Apex Court has held that facts and circumstances of the case have to be considered and the court has not to apply or follow the general propositions relating to bank guarantee cases, regardless of the facts peculiar to each case. The judgement suggests that invocation of bank guarantee is not justified merely because the party invoking the bank guarantee has some claim of damages against the party who furnished the bank guarantee. It has been held that a claim for damages is not a crystallised or ascertained amount or a sum due and payable in praesenti( meaning ‘at present’), therefore invocation of bank guarantee would not be justified on the basis of such claim which are yet to the decided by the competent forum. The court further held that bank guarantee given for searching the performance of one contract cannot be invoked for claims or disputes in another contract between the same parties. This judgment has to some extent diluted the position that an unconditional bank guarantee can be invoked regardless of the dispute between the beneficiary and the principal obligation. The Supreme Court in some ways has supplemented to the line of authority of judgments against invocation of bank guarantee by beneficiary like the Hindustan Construction Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar, which held that the invocation of bank guarantee will have to be strictly in accordance with the terms of the contract/Bank guarantee deed.

This judgement of Gangotri Enterprises will certainly come to the rescue of litigants, primarily contractors executing work under contracts awarded by government agencies and the said agencies were exercising unbridled discretion in the matter of encashment of bank guarantees furnished by the contractor. A general belief that bank guarantees can beencashed irrespective of the main dispute between the contractor and the department, or for covering the claims for damage, which are yet to be crystallized, has been set right but this judgement. Therefore, whenever any party would seek to encash the bank guarantees provided by other party to the contract on the basis of their claims of damages, such an attempt would not be successful as a claim of damages is not a sum due and payable in present. Similarly, bank guarantee given for one contract cannot be encashed for breaches/disputes concerning to another contract.

Comments (18)

  1. Sekaran Sebastian says on 08 Jan 2019

    Dear Sir/ Mam,I am a mandate to an Investment Company who is a premier provider of bank instruments such as BG SBLC MTN DLC LC as well as discountable bank instruments;We are specialist in providing Genuine Bank Guarantees, Standby Letter of Credit, Pre Advice / RWA Messages, Documentary Letters of Credit, Bank Draft, Proof of Funds, Performance Bond, Medium Term Notes, and various SWIFT messaging services on lease and sale. We issue these instruments from prime banks, secondary banks, and financial institutions; and transmit SWIFT MT 760, MT 799, MT199, MT999 and other messages on behalf of our clients.We offer certifiable and verifiable bank instruments via Swift Transmission from a genuine provider capable of taking up time bound transactions. We are RWA ready to close leasing with any interested client in few banking days.Kindly contact for genuine inquiries and I can provider you with the needed information.Email: bglease.sekaran@gmail.comSkype: bglease.sekaran@outlook.com

  2. NM says on 14 Jan 2019

    Informative

  3. Tejashvi says on 22 May 2019

    Thank you for the information, to get loan against bank guarantee visit https://balajicredits.com/loan-against-bank-guarantee/

  4. findlay graham says on 04 Oct 2019

  5. Thomas Cronin says on 03 Jul 2021

    We are trusted trade finance solution providers who is here to help you keep your supply chain moving smoothly in order to lead you to business growth. Offering you a range of trade finance solutions and services including Letter of Credit (USANCE and AT SIGHT, Back to Back LC), Standby Letters of Credit (SBLC), Bank Guarantee (BG), Performance Guarantees ,Advance payment Guarantees, Proof of Funds (POF), Blocked Funds, Bank Drafts, Pre-Advice messages, Bank Comfort letters , Ready Willing and Able (RWA) and more.With experience in handling clients of businesses of all sizes, we have the knowledge and the expertise to offer you a proven trade finance solution for your situation. Whether you are a trader, an importer, exporter, introducer, a consultant, or a broker we are here to offer you integrated trade finance solutions for reasonable service costs.* FOR LEASING OF BG/SBLC MINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MLEASING FEE = 4% 2%* FOR PURCHASE OF FRESH CUT BG/SBLC MINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MPRICE = 32% 2%We also have Trusted monetizer partners who can Monetize BG/SBLC at good rates. They also can receive the BG/SBLC on behlf of the beneficiary to give a Non Recourse Loan*Leased BG/SBLC Monetization - 65% Non Recourse*Purchased BG/SBLC Monetization - 90% Non Recourse.if you are interested in our quality services, kindly reach out via the information belowContact Person :Thomas Email : dpfinanciallimited@gmail.comPhone/Whatsapp : 1(516)856-5370Skype : dpfinanciallimited@gmail.com

  6. thomas wolfgang says on 20 Jul 2021

    GENUINE BANK GUARANTEE (BG) AND STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT (SBLC) FOR BUY OR LEASE AT THE BEST AVAILABLE RATESWe offer certified and verifiable financial bank instruments via Swift Transmission from a genuine provider capableof taking up time bound transactions.FOR LEASING OF BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MLEASING FEE = 4% 2%FOR PURCHASE OF FRESH CUT BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MPRICE = 32% 2%Our BG/SBLC Financing can help you get your project funded, loan financing by providing you with yearly. RWA ready to close leasing with any interested client in few banking daysI will be glad to share with you our working procedures.Name : Thomas WolfgangEmail : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.comSkype : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.com

  7. Jason Edward says on 25 Jul 2021

    FINANCIAL AGENT LIMITED provides a full financial planning service to both the commercial and domestic markets. At IQ FINANCE PLC we believe that financial planning is about two things: creating wealth and protecting wealth. These two objectives are at the heart of everything we do. And, as a member of FINANCIAL AGENT LIMITED Services, we give you a small-company service but with a large-company set up – the best of both worlds.  You are at liberty to engage our leased facilities into trade programs as well as in signature project(s) such as Aviation, Agriculture, Petroleum, Telecommunication, construction of Dams, Bridges and any other turnkey project(s) etc. Our terms and Conditions are reasonable. Leasing Price : 6% 2%Buying Price: 38% 2%Contact us for more details on our terms and procedure of transaction.NAME  :Jason EdwardEMAIL :financialagentltd@gmail.comSKYPE :financialagentltd@gmail.com    

  8. nbfcfunding says on 30 Jul 2021

    Good news, Are you in need of financial assistance for business, personal, educational or Project purposes? Search no further, we can help you finance your business or personal needs at an affordable interest rate. Contact us now for more details through company Email managealic@gmail.comWhatsApp 91-742-814-2745

  9. thomas wolfgang says on 16 Aug 2021

    GENUINE BANK GUARANTEE (BG) AND STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT (SBLC) FOR BUY OR LEASE AT THE BEST AVAILABLE RATESWe offer certified and verifiable financial bank instruments via Swift Transmission from a genuine provider capableof taking up time bound transactions.FOR LEASING OF BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MLEASING FEE = 4% 2%FOR PURCHASE OF FRESH CUT BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MPRICE = 32% 2%Our BG/SBLC Financing can help you get your project funded, loan financing by providing you with yearly. RWA ready to close leasing with any interested client in few banking daysI will be glad to share with you our working procedures.Name : Thomas WolfgangEmail : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.comSkype : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.com

  10. thomas wolfgang says on 16 Aug 2021

    GENUINE BANK GUARANTEE (BG) AND STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT (SBLC) FOR BUY OR LEASE AT THE BEST AVAILABLE RATESWe offer certified and verifiable financial bank instruments via Swift Transmission from a genuine provider capableof taking up time bound transactions.FOR LEASING OF BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MLEASING FEE = 4% 2%FOR PURCHASE OF FRESH CUT BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MPRICE = 32% 2%Our BG/SBLC Financing can help you get your project funded, loan financing by providing you with yearly. RWA ready to close leasing with any interested client in few banking daysI will be glad to share with you our working procedures.Name : Thomas WolfgangEmail : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.comSkype : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.com

  11. thomas wolfgang says on 20 Aug 2021

    GENUINE BANK GUARANTEE (BG) AND STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT (SBLC) FOR BUY OR LEASE AT THE BEST AVAILABLE RATESWe offer certified and verifiable financial bank instruments via Swift Transmission from a genuine provider capableof taking up time bound transactions.FOR LEASING OF BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MLEASING FEE = 4% 2%FOR PURCHASE OF FRESH CUT BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MPRICE = 32% 2%Our BG/SBLC Financing can help you get your project funded, loan financing by providing you with yearly. RWA ready to close leasing with any interested client in few banking daysI will be glad to share with you our working procedures.Name : Thomas WolfgangEmail : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.comSkype : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.com

  12. Jason Edward says on 26 Aug 2021

    FINANCIAL AGENT LIMITED provides a full financial planning service to both the commercial and domestic markets. At IQ FINANCE PLC we believe that financial planning is about two things: creating wealth and protecting wealth. These two objectives are at the heart of everything we do. And, as a member of FINANCIAL AGENT LIMITED Services, we give you a small-company service but with a large-company set up – the best of both worlds. You are at liberty to engage our leased facilities into trade programs as well as in signature project(s) such as Aviation, Agriculture, Petroleum, Telecommunication, construction of Dams, Bridges and any other turnkey project(s) etc. Our terms and Conditions are reasonable. Leasing Price : 6% 2%Buying Price: 38% 2%Contact us for more details on our terms and procedure of transaction.NAME :Jason EdwardEMAIL :financialagentltd@gmail.comSKYPE :financialagentltd@gmail.com

  13. ( IFSCapitalloan@gmail.com ) OFFER ALL KIND OF LOANS - APPLY FOR AFFORDABLE LOANS ( IFSCapital@post.com ) says on 30 Aug 2021

    ( IFSCapitalloan@gmail.com ) OFFER ALL KIND OF LOANS - APPLY FOR AFFORDABLE LOANS ( IFSCapital@post.com )Do You Need A Loan To Consolidate Your Debt At 1%? IF YES Contact Us @ Via Email: ( RMPCapitals@gmail.com ) RMPCapitals@usa.com Or A Personal Loans * Business Loans etc. Interested Parties Should Contact Us For More Information Via Email: ( RMPCapitals@usa.com ) RMPCapitals@gmail.com Please Fill the Application Form Below: -Complete Name: -Loan amount needed: -Loan Duration: -Purpose of loan: -City / Country: -Telephone: -Name Of The Site You/Link Hear About Us:( IFSCapitalLoan@gmail.com ) OFFER ALL KIND OF LOANS - APPLY FOR AFFORDABLE LOANS ( IFSCapital@post.com )Do You Need A Loan To Consolidate Your Debt At 1%? SuiteCapitals@gmail.com ( SuiteCapitals@post.com ) Or A Personal Loans * Business Loans etc. Interested Parties Should Contact Us For More Information Via Email: ( SuiteCapitals@post.com ) SuiteCapitals@gmail.com ( IFSCapitalloan@gmail.com ) OFFER ALL KIND OF LOANS - APPLY FOR AFFORDABLE LOANS ( IFSCapital@post.com )( CYSCredits@Asia.com ) CYSCredits@Post.com Is Offering Global Fund Program, Where Loans Are Offered To Interested Clients Globally To Fund Profitable Business And Projects. Contact Us For More Information Via Email: ( CYSCredits@Asia.com ) CYSCredits@Post.com ( IFSCapitalloan@gmail.com ) OFFER ALL KIND OF LOANS - APPLY FOR AFFORDABLE LOANS ( IFSCapital@post.com )ValidusCapital@techie.com Are The Solution To Your Financial Problem, ValidusCapital@execs.com Has Set Itself The Mission Of Promoting Short, Medium And Long-Term Loan Financing And Borrow Flexibly! Our Program Are Financial Institutions To Fund Private Capital, Private Equity, Project Funding, Real Estate, Business

  14. Carlos says on 31 Aug 2021

    wafaahack@gmail.com    or whatsApp:  32460224954, is a professional hacking team, We are professional ,we get your work done in less than 24 hours. We provide the following services and more;* HACK INTO WHATSAPP, FACEBOOK, EMAIL BOX, INSTAGRAM, TEXT MESSAGES ETC.* RECOVER YOUR MONEY FROM ANY KIND OF SCAMMERS.* FREE BITCOIN LOADING AND PAYPAL LOADING, WE SHARE ON %.* MOBILE PHONE MONITOR/HACK.* HACK AND CHANGE UNIVERSITY GRADES* HACK INTO ANY BANK WEBSITE AND DO MONEY TRANSFER.* HACK INTO ANY COMPANY WEBSITE.* HACK INTO ANY GOVERNMENT AGENCY WEBSITE.* HACK INTO ANY DATABASE SYSTEM AND GRANT YOU ADMIN PRIVILEGES.* HACK PAYPAL ACCOUNT.* HACK WORDPRESS BLOGS.* SERVER CRASHED HACK.* Untraceable IP and so much more....* We can restore LOST FILES AND DOCUMENTS , no matter how long they have been missing.NOTE:If you refer a client to us as a result of the previous job done for you, you will stand a chance of getting any job of your choice hacked for you free of charge.We can also teach you how to do the following with our ebook and online tutorials* Hack and use Credit Card to shop online.* Monitor any phone and email address.* Hack Android

  15. lee says on 05 Sep 2021

    hello how are you doing ??This is to inform the public that Ms. mercy, personal loan lenders financial opportunity for those who need financial assistance. We provide loan interest rate by 3% for individuals, businesses and corporations in accordance with the terms that are clear and easy to understand. contact us today via email: lee944418@gmail.com

  16. Kenneth Jones says on 13 Sep 2021

    I know of a group of private investigators who can help you with they are also hackers but prefer to be called private investigators They can help with your bitcoin issues and your clients will be happy doing business with you,they can also help yo with your bad credit score and you will live a better lifeContact 1(407) 777-4240Premiumhackservices@gmail.com

  17. thomas wolfgang says on 16 Sep 2021

    GENUINE BANK GUARANTEE (BG) AND STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT (SBLC) FOR BUY OR LEASE AT THE BEST AVAILABLE RATESWe offer certified and verifiable financial bank instruments via Swift Transmission from a genuine provider capableof taking up time bound transactions.FOR LEASING OF BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MLEASING FEE = 4% 2%FOR PURCHASE OF FRESH CUT BG/SBLCMINIMUM FACE VALUE OF BG/SBLC = EUR/USD 1MPRICE = 32% 2%Our BG/SBLC Financing can help you get your project funded, loan financing by providing you with yearly. RWA ready to close leasing with any interested client in few banking daysI will be glad to share with you our working procedures.Name : Thomas WolfgangEmail : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.comSkype : inquiry.fastfunding@gmail.com

  18. Carlos says on 17 Sep 2021

    wafaahack@gmail.com    or whatsApp:  32460224954   is a professional hacking team worldwide, we get your work done in less than 24 hours. We provide the following services and more;* HACK INTO WHATSAPP, FACEBOOK, EMAIL BOX, INSTAGRAM, TEXT MESSAGES ETC.* GENERAL PHONE HACKING AND SPY,* RECOVER YOUR MONEY FROM SCAMMERS.* FREE BITCOIN LOADING AND PAYPAL LOADING, WE SHARE ON %.* MOBILE PHONE MONITOR/HACK.* HACK, UPGRADE AND CHANGE UNIVERSITY GRADES.* HACK INTO ANY BANK WEBSITE AND TRANSFER MONEY.* HACK INTO ANY COMPANY WEBSITE DATABASE.* HACK INTO ANY GOVERNMENT AGENCY WEBSITE DATABASE.* HACK INTO ANY DATABASE SYSTEM AND GRANT YOU ADMIN PRIVILEGES.* BUY HACKED PAYPAL ACCOUNT.* HACK WORDPRESS BLOGS.* SERVER CRASHED HACK.* BUY VERIFIED AND GENUINE  INTERNATIONAL PASSPORT OF ANY COUNTRIES OF YOUR CHOICE.* Untraceable IP and so much more....* We can restore LOST FILES AND DOCUMENTS , no matter how long they have been missing.NOTE:If you refer a client to us as a result of  previous job done for you, you will stand a chance of getting any hacking of your choice done free of charge.We can also teach you how to do the following with our ebook and online tutorials* Hack and use Credit Card to shop online.* Monitor any phone and email address.* Hack Android

Post Comments

Search

Other Articles / Blogs by the Author

Practice Areas

Archives


Authors


Our social activites

Social Updates